|
The I-search Paper
Originally devised by the late Ken McCrorie
The I-search paper helps you, as a student, to incorporate
the story of the search itself into the writing of the paper. It
also permits you to search for the answer to a question which is personally
important rather than choosing a topic that may have little bearing on
your life and little connection to your personal interests. To find
out more about writing an I-search paper, go to the following links:
If you have a problem at any point in composing your I-Search Paper,
you can always seek help at Delta's Teachling/Learning Center, in the
LLIC. The web site address is http://www.delta.edu/tlc
Their e-mail address is tlc@alpha.delta.edu
The Assignment
An I-search paper calls for you to tell virtually every step of the
search which led to the answer of your question, including the dead-ends
and failures, which means that you can be drafting your paper as you
proceed with your search rather than waiting until you have all the
information you need before deciding upon what you will actually write.
It also means that you can tell your readers of your frustrations
as you underwent your search. Even if you have not found an answer
to your question, you can still write your paper, explaining to your
readers at the end of your paper that your question remains unanswered
and describing what you did learn that was worthwhile or how you would
amend your search on a future attempt.
Things to bear in mind when writing an I-search paper:
- the topic is private but the language must be public and appropriately
academic
- citation procedures must be followed as though writing a regular
research paper
- the paper must be appealing to a general academic audience
Return to Top
The Question
Spend some time deciding upon and formulating your question. Do
some brainstorming to come up with a list of several possible questions,
and explain to yourself in writing why some of those questions would
lead to an interesting search. Ask yourself what is at stake in
answering some of the questions. Ideally, if an I-search question
can be answered then the searcher should be able to do something which
was impossible without the answer to the question. Here are some
sample I-search questions:
- What would be the best university for my major?
- What are the implications for me that there is a history of alcoholism
in my family?
- Is there a chance to begin a new career for someone who is forty
years old?
- Should I permit my deaf child to learn American Sign Language?
- What is entailed in starting up a small business?
Return to Top
The Lead
All I-search papers must begin with an interesting lead, something which
pulls your readers into your paper. Most leads take the form of
a narrative, a story relating where in your life your question came from.
Here is a sample lead:
I found myself in this country two
years ago, an immigrant from Cambodia who had grown up learning English
but had very little experience actually speaking it every day.
In those two years I lived with generous people who helped me greatly
to learn how to speak English and who helped me improve my reading and
writing skills. I have become a citizen of this country, and now
I am ready to go to a university and learn how to be a computer programmer.
My life in this country has been full of good fortune and success, thanks
mainly to the good people who took me into their home. One thing
I am worried about, though, as I prepare to go to a big university.
I am a very shy person who has lived quietly in a beautiful house.
Before I came to this country, I spent over a year sleeping on the ground,
often not sleeping at all, so afraid was I of being captured by the
Khmer Rouge. I saw many people being killed and came across many
dead bodies as a fled from the country of my birth. I am twenty
years old and have never known what it is to be like an American teenager.
When I see young people in this country, they look so carefree to me,
even though I know there are problems with drugs and alcohol.
I do not want to be made fun of when I go to university. I do
not want to be lonely. So, my question is how do I fit into the
life of American young people in a large university?
Return to Top
The I-search Journal
It is almost impossible to undertake an I-search without keeping a journal,
however informal. Carry a notebook with you while working on the
I-search and keep note of dates and times of everything you do, along
with the following details:
- Every visit to the Library, including search method employed, titles
of books or articles perused, along with their call numbers, names
of helpful library staff, and so on. Be sure to include details
of failed or frustrated searches.
- Appointments made for personal interviews, including the locations.
- Each use of the computer, including URL's of websites and e-mail
addresses of people or institutions contacted.
- Descriptions of places visited for interviews. (People
who are undertaking job search interviews may find that the
physical surroundings in which interviewees work could make a difference
as to whether the job appears to be appealing or not.)
- Brief notes of your reactions to events, situations, and information
you encounter. Letting your readers know how you react to what
you find is most important.
- Brief notes of interview or library search information. Of
course, you will be keeping more extensive notes elsewhere or as photocopies,
print-outs, or audio tapes.
Consider keeping a dual entry log. Simply draw a line down the
center of your note paper. On the left side of that line write down
quotes from an interview, lines from something you have read, or visual
impressions from a site visit you made. On the right side of the line
write your reactions to these observations. Later, you can transfer
the details and your reactions to your actual paper.
Return to Top
Conducting the Personal Interviews
The most important information in an I-search can come from personal
interviews. Very often, those interviews are with busy people who
have generously given up time to answer questions. Students locate
such people through their college or university resources, through a library
search, by looking in the Yellow Pages, or by personal reference from
classmates, relatives, co-workers, or friends. Sometimes a helpful
resource is discovered via an Internet source, in which case the interview
might be conducted via e-mail. Some interviews can also be conducted
over the telephone, although it is often preferable to see the interviewee
in person because surroundings, body language, and other matters can offer
valuable information.
When making the interview appointment, be sure to mention how long
you expect the interview to last and the kind of information you will
be seeking. That way, the interviewee can set aside time and,
perhaps, retrieve written information to hand to you when you come to
the interview.
Dress appropriately for the interview. Try to ancitipate the
kind of appearance which is expected from people in the environment
you will be entering and try to blend in as much as your wardrobe and
clothing expenses will permit.
At the interview, remember that you must ask permission to use a tape
recorder. That is the law. If the interviewee refuses permission,
you must abide by that refusal.
Have questions prepared that are substantial and really help you answer
your I-search question. Even so, listen carefully to the responses
you receive and be prepared to follow up on an interesting line of information.
You are the time keeper. If time is running short, let your interviewee
know and let him or her decide whether or not the interview should be
brought to a close or permitted to go on further. Sometimes a
follow-up interview can be arranged if you want more information and
have run out of time.
Always be polite, and follow up the interview with a thank-you letter.
Even a card would be adequate.
Return to Top
The Library Search
Your instructor or handbook can supply you with useful information
about undertaking the library search, but valuable information can also
be found at the following website:
The Research Station
Return to Top
The Career Search
Your institution may have a career center that can be
of enormous help with your search. Delta College's Career Center includes
lists of past students in various lines of work who are willing to
be interviewed or even shadowed at their workplace.
Another source of information is the Michigan Occupational
Index, which can be accessed by clicking on the following link: MOIS.
Return to Top
The Internet Search
Bruce Ballenger, author of a wonderful book for research
writers entitled The Curious Researcher, reminds us that the
Internet can seem to be readily accessible and fast, but the amount
of information we often receive during our Internet searches can be
overwhelming, and there is always the problem of knowing for certain
that the information we receive is valid. Carefully validate all your
sources through the following procedure:
- Check the author. If no information on the author can be found, that
might indicate a problem. If a web site has no author's name, check
the name of the organization sponsoring the information. Look for sound
qualifications and for any signs of bias.
- Check the sponsoring organization. Some organizations represent special
interest groups, which means that the information they disseminate might
be biased in favor of that group's point of view.
- In the case of magazines or newspapers, make sure that they are reputable
publications who are accountable for the accuracy and fairness of the
information they publish. Professional and scholarly journals only publish
articles that have been critiqued by the peers of the authors, which
means that information contained in such journals tends to be more reliable
than that contained in popular magazines or newspapers.
- In the case of statistics, government documents are the most reliable
source.
- Check the publication date of the information. You do not want to
be working with information that is out of date.
Organizing
the Internet
Searching
the Internet
Search Engines
and Indexes
Return to Top
The Story of the Search
The story of your search should be both interesting and informative.
It should also be written in formal academic language even though you
are essentially writing about something only you may benefit from, although
most I-search papers contain information that is helpful to virtually
all who read them. As you write up the story of your search, keep
in mind the following pointers:
- The paper should begin with an interesting lead.
- The I-search question should be explicitly
stated following the lead.
- The information should be selected for a general audience
of academic readers. Any information which might be too technical
should be explained and any lengthy tables or technical lists should
be avoided. They can be moved to an appendix coming after the
Works Cited or Reference page if necessary.
- Include actual dialogue or actual words spoken where you feel it
would be appropriate.
- Include rich descriptions of the places and people you visit where
you feel such description would interest your readers and contribute
to the answer to your question.
- After each piece of information, let your readers know how this
information contributes to the answer to your question.
- Follow the citation guidelines stipulated by your instructor, or
you may select either MLA or APA citation guidelines to follow.
Follow them exactly as though you were writing a more conventional
research paper.
Return to Top
The Conclusion
The conclusion to your I-search paper can take many forms. Generally,
it contains an explanation of the success you have had in answering your
question and what you intend to do now that you have the answer you wanted.
Sometimes, your conclusion might explain to your readers that you failed
to answer your question but that you did gather some interesting information
and have now changed your question to continue your search. At other
times, a student might express disappointment, or even anger, at how difficult
it was to find answers to a question which he or she feels to be
crucial. That anger may result in a determination to discover why
it is that so little information is readily available on an important
topic. All the conclusions must be interesting and leave your readers
with something to think about, now that they have experienced your search
with you. Here are sample conclusions:
This conclusion was written for a paper searching the career of radiography:
Now that I have done the research
for my question, I finally have come to the conclusion that I do have
what it takes to be a good radiographer and succeed in the medical community.
What helped me the most in answering my question was the article from
Exploring Health Care Careers and the personal interviews I had
with Lois and Janet from the Ambulatory Care Center. Most importantly,
I had to search deep down in my soul and really think if I had it in
me to take on such a demanding career, both physically and emotionally.
When I interviewed Janet and Lois, they helped me answer that question
because they are the front line each and every day, giving comfort and
moral support to the patients. Through their words and the way
they seemed to enjoy their work and show to others around them how they
are successful in their career, I learned what it means to be a devoted
health care worker. Before this search, I never was really sure
that I could do whatever I set out to do in life. This paper has
been a great self-esteem booster for me because it showed me that I
can do anything I plan to do, no matter what it is. To succeed,
people must be aware of their own traits, and we must search our hearts
and souls to choose our paths in life. We can either take the
path life has chosen for us or we can choose the path that we want to
be happy and successful in life. The path I have chosen is to
become successful in radiography.
Here is a concluding paragraph to a paper searching for information
on sexual child abuse:
I started out this I-search with
the question, "What makes a child molester do such terrible things to
children?" I have answered that question, but it has not made
me feel any better about what happened to me as a child. Now I
realize that I really want to know why he did it to me.
Why did he choose me? I will never know the answer to that question,
especially since I never want to meet or speak to my abuser. I
wanted to lose the anger I have felt all my life, and now I know that
I probably never will. The I-search has failed me because I was
asking the wrong question.
These conclusions illustrate searches that were both successful and
unsuccessful. The conclusion to the unsuccessful I-search might
well have contained a synopsis of what was learned, but in light of
the writer's feelings about the search, a reluctance to review the information
gathered might be understandable. The point is to gain insight
and make discoveries, which was what occurred for both the above writers.
I wish every I-searcher success.
Return to Top
|